Bids & specialty rooms

How to read and compare a commercial drywall bid

Two drywall bids for the same job can be thousands of dollars apart and both be honest. The difference is usually in what each one includes. Here’s how to read a framing, drywall and ceiling bid line by line, and how to compare them fairly.

Key takeaways

  • A good bid breaks out each scope on its own line, says what’s labor only and what includes materials, and lists exclusions.
  • Compare bids line by line. Most price gaps are scope gaps.
  • Check the finish level, the wall heights, the doors, the patch-backs and the clean-up.
  • Ask about unit prices for adds, sales tax, retainage and lien waivers before you sign.

What a clear bid looks like

Our estimates list each scope as its own line, with a plain description and a price. For the full build-out at Richmond Ave, the scope broke out like this:

  • Wall framing: 3-5/8" and 6" metal studs, some to deck and some to 6" above grid; 5/8" Type X board; purple moisture-resistant board at bathrooms; frame, sheetrock, tape, float, skim, sand and touch up
  • Demolition: walls, doors, cabinets and suspended ceiling downstairs, with clean-up
  • Doors and trim: labor only, 12 frames and doors, listed by size and type
  • Ceilings: labor and materials, 15/16" grid with 2×2 reveal-edge tile, and a separate line for all-aluminum grid
  • Structural openings: demolition for beams, reinstalling grid and ceiling, and re-drywalling and finishing
  • Additional framing: walls at the stairs and an upstairs window, to the deck
  • Insulation: labor and materials, R-11 at all walls

Because every line stands alone, the general contractor and the owner could see exactly what they were buying, compare it to other bids and adjust scope without re-pricing the whole job.

Line by line: what to check

ScopeQuestions to ask
FramingWhich wall types and heights? To deck or above grid? Deflection track and bracing included? Backing included, and where?
BoardType X throughout? Moisture-resistant where? Number of layers on rated and sound walls? Ceilings and soffits included?
FinishWhich GA-214 level, and where? Does “ready for paint” include sanding and touch-up after primer?
CeilingsGrid type and face, tile product and edge, square footage? Who sets fixtures and diffusers into the grid?
InsulationWhich walls, what R-value, any sound sealant?
DoorsLabor only or furnished? How many, what sizes? Hardware included or not?
DemolitionWhat’s removed? Who supplies the dumpster? Is clean-up included?

Exclusions that become change orders

Read the exclusions as carefully as the inclusions. These are the items most often left out of one bid and included in another:

  • Firestopping at penetrations and fire caulk at the head of rated walls
  • Acoustical sealant and putty pads at sound walls
  • Backing and blocking not shown on the drawings
  • Patch-backs after the electrician, plumber and HVAC installer
  • Door hardware, access panels and FRP
  • Lifts, scaffolding, after-hours or weekend work
  • Permits, engineering and testing
  • Dumpsters and haul-off

Comparing bids fairly

  1. Make a scope sheet listing every item above, and mark each bid included, excluded or unclear.
  2. Level the bids by adding a fair number for anything one bidder excluded and another included.
  3. Call about the unclear items. A five-minute conversation saves a change order.
  4. Ask for unit prices for likely adds: per lineal foot of wall by type, per door, per square foot of ceiling. They make changes fast and fair.

Money terms worth asking about

  • Sales tax. Texas taxes some construction work and not others; remodeling existing nonresidential property is treated differently from new construction. The bid should say whether tax is included, and your GC or accountant should confirm how it applies.
  • Retainage. Ask how much of each payment will be held back and when it is released.
  • Lien waivers. Texas uses statutory forms for conditional and unconditional waivers. Expect to exchange them with each payment.
  • Schedule of values. On lender-financed projects, the bid lines often become the subcontractor’s schedule of values for monthly pay applications, another reason to keep them clear.

Common questions

Why do drywall bids vary so much?

Mostly scope. One bid may include ceilings, insulation, doors and demolition while another covers framing and board only, or assumes a lower finish level, labor-only doors or no patch-backs. Put the bids side by side line by line before comparing totals.

Should drywall bids include sales tax?

The bid should say clearly whether tax is included. In Texas, how sales tax applies depends on the job, notably whether it is new construction or the remodeling of existing nonresidential property, so confirm with your GC or accountant.

What is retainage?

A percentage of each payment held back until the work is complete, protecting the owner and GC. Ask how much will be held and when it will be released, and plan cash flow around it.

Have plans to price?

Send drawings or a scope sheet. We price framing, board, finish, grid, insulation and doors as one package, line by line.

Request a bid